Kialo requires JavaScript to work correctly.
Should we stop telling the “miracle of the lamp oil” story for Hanukkah?
Loading Discussion
Selected thesis
We should stop telling the "miracle of the lamp oil" story for Hanukkah.
Pros
Cons
Pro claim 1
The "miracle of the lamp oil" story detracts from the many other important stories of Hanukkah.
Pro claim 2
Scholars question the historical accuracy of the "miracle of the lamp oil" story.
Con claim 1
The “miracle of the lamp oil” story symbolizes hope and faith, which are key to Hanukkah.
Con claim 2
The “miracle of the lamp oil” story helps young children to understand Hanukkah.